If you said “hmmmmm, I’m not sure about that” when you heard that Timotheé Chalamet had been cast as Bob Dylan, your can rest your fears and rejoice because the young star is excellent as the legendary singer/songwriter. He nails Dylan’s nasally mumbling speech patterns and he also sings and plays guitar with style and passion in the new film A Complete Unknown. For music fans, it’s a “must see.”

Chalamet and director/co-writer James Mangold do a nice job of contrasting the raw rookie Dylan of the early 1960s with the very different Dylan of 1965. The early Dylan who rolls into New York is aware of his own talent but needs audiences. One of his first is Woody Guthrie (Scoot McNairy) who is bedridden in a New Jersey sanitarium. 

It’s there he meets folk music icon Pete Seeger who give his young friend a strong leg up. Dylan’s relationship with Pete Seeger (Edward Norton) which goes from warm to icy, as Dylan gears up to take his music to a new level, is one of the film’s key conflicts. Here was the young savior of folk music who did the traditional folk songs as well as his own compositions in the style of the folk legends of the day. Would he follow Pete’s will and stay within the strict boundaries of the Newport FOLK Festival?

Dylan had bigger dreams. As fans know, he had a prolific period in 1965 and 1966 which saw him release three new albums (one of those a double album) in just over a year. He also had his first hit single which introduced him to America via Top 40 radio and contained the lyric that gives this movie its title. Those three albums were not like the ones that had come before. One of the cool scenes in the film is Dylan and his band playing the song Highway 61 Revisited—complete with police siren whistle!—in a recording studio. 

The 1965 version of Dylan in the movie is cool, detached, arrogant. He’s made some money, rides a motorcycle and is surrounded by adoring fans. He has an attitude.

Another of the film’s conflicts is the hot and cold relationship Bob has with Joan Baez (Monica Barbaro). Their songs together are among the film’s top musical moments, not unlike the memorable duets in Mangold’s 2005 biopic Walk The Line between Johnny Cash and June Carter (Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon). More conflict: Dylan’s girlfriend Sylvie (Elle Fanning) has enough of Bob and Joan and departs Newport just before the film’s climax. And, by the way, Cash (Boyd Holbrook) was a few moments in this film.

Looking back six decades later, it doesn’t seem that Dylan’s “going electric” was that big a deal. More like just another event in the rapidly changing pop culture scene of that tumultuous decade. But—at the time—it was a big deal. And it’s the crux of Bob Dylan’s evolution and the next step in the dawn of the folk/rock era as presented here.

A Complete Unknown is the best kind of biopic because it doesn’t try to cram decades of its subject’s life into a couple of hours. It focuses instead on just two distinct periods in the early years of this musical icon. And like the best movies that include music, the music is just as vital to the film as the story. Maybe even more vital. The songs provide the film’s most magical moments.

Not that it matters, but A Complete Unknown has already received awards nominations and more are sure to come. Chalamet, Norton, Barbaro and Mangold could be holding trophies soon. And even though the Dylan songs in the film are too old to be considered for new awards, wouldn’t it be cool to have Timotheé Chalamet perform a Dylan classic or two on the Oscars telecast?

Among my feelings after seeing A Complete Unknown is a desire to rewatch the movie Inside Llewyn Davis a 2013 Coen brothers film about a talented young folk singer in New York in 1961 who keeps making missteps and running into bad luck. That film, like this one, recreates the era beautifully even if the fictional tale is not so beautiful. 

To be sure, there are many more Dylan stories to be told and Dylan songs to be sung. Would Chalamet and Mangold want to tackle those in a future film? Is it completely insane to suggest such a thing even before this movie has been released? Maybe a romantic film focusing on Dylan and Joan Baez in their times together in California and upstate New York? Would that work?

Sorry for thinking too far ahead. Let’s just enjoy this superb movie A Complete Unknown right now and not worry too much about what may be blowing in the wind.